top of page

THE WEEKEND VAR TOOK OVER BMO

One stadium. Two matches. Two handball decisions.



Some weekends are remembered for spectacular goals.

Others are remembered for unforgettable performances.

At BMO Stadium, this weekend will be remembered for something else.

VAR.

Across two days, LAFC supporters celebrated a goal that never counted. Angel City supporters did the same less than 24 hours later. Between those moments came a late penalty, another walk to the monitor, and three separate handball decisions that reshaped two matches played on the same field.

The football never stopped talking.

VAR simply kept interrupting the conversation.



Saturday: Celebration Turns to Silence

The first major moment arrived just over 20 minutes into LAFC's Western Conference clash with San Diego FC.

Timothy Tillman lifted a ball over the defense. Denis Bouanga brought it down and finished confidently past goalkeeper CJ dos Santos. BMO Stadium erupted.

For a few moments, it looked like LAFC had done exactly what it often does at home—strike first and force the opposition to chase the game.

Then everyone looked toward the referee.

VAR had identified handball contact during Bouanga's first touch. Referee Ismail Elfath was sent to the monitor, reviewed the play, and overturned the goal.

Just like that, the scoreboard returned to 0-0.

So did the emotion inside the stadium.

By the letter of the Laws of the Game, the decision aligned with the current interpretation of attacking handball in the immediate buildup to a goal. But for supporters inside BMO, the experience felt different.

One moment they were celebrating.

The next they were wondering what they had missed.



Then Came the Defining Moment

For much of the night, the match remained balanced.

LAFC controlled long stretches of possession, San Diego stayed organized, and every attack felt increasingly important as time disappeared from the clock.

Then, in the 89th minute, another pause.

Another review.

Another handball.

San Diego earned a corner, and during the scramble inside the penalty area, the ball struck Ryan Porteous' raised arm. Play continued briefly before VAR recommended another review.

Elfath returned to the monitor.

This time, he pointed to the penalty spot.

Anders Dreyer converted from twelve yards.

San Diego celebrated.

LAFC's unbeaten run came to an end.

The decision fit current handball guidance regarding defenders whose arm position makes the body unnaturally bigger. Even so, the lasting image wasn't the penalty itself.

It was another crowd waiting in silence for a screen to deliver the final verdict.



Twenty-Four Hours Later, the Story Returned

Sunday belonged to Angel City FC.

The feeling, however, was familiar.

Ally Sentnor believed she had scored her first goal for Angel City after a buildup involving Prisca Chilufya.

The celebrations had barely settled before play stopped once again.

VAR reviewed the sequence.

Referee Alyssa Pennington walked to the monitor.

The goal was overturned after officials determined there had been a handball during the buildup.

Different teams.

Different referee.

Same stadium.

Same emotional journey.

Angel City eventually found an equalizer late through Sentnor, rescuing a point against the Washington Spirit, but the conversation after the match had already shifted.

Not toward the finish.

Toward another handball.

Toward another VAR review.



More Than Three Decisions

Viewed separately, each decision can be explained through the current interpretation of the Laws of the Game.

Bouanga's goal was ruled out because attacking handball directly contributed to the scoring sequence.

Porteous was penalized because his raised arm was judged to have made his body unnaturally bigger inside the penalty area.

Angel City's goal was overturned after officials determined handball had occurred during the buildup.

Three incidents.

Three reviews.

Three decisions that fit within today's interpretation of the law.

Yet football is experienced in real time—not in freeze frames.

Inside the stadium, supporters didn't experience legal definitions.

They experienced emotion.

Celebration.

Confusion.

Silence.

The referee walking toward the monitor.

Hope.

Frustration.

Relief for one side.

Disbelief for the other.

Each review followed almost the same script.



When Technology Becomes Part of the Match

VAR exists to help referees correct clear and obvious errors.

This weekend, it did exactly what it was designed to do.

The officials reviewed incidents they believed required another look and made decisions based on the available video.

But another question naturally emerged.

When does technology stop correcting the game and start becoming one of its main characters?

Across two matches at BMO Stadium, some of the most memorable moments weren't goals or saves.

They were pauses.

They were walks to the monitor.

They were thousands of supporters watching a replay instead of watching football.

That doesn't necessarily mean the decisions were wrong.

It means the experience of modern football continues to evolve.



The Fieldtalk View

The handball law wasn't rewritten this weekend.

VAR didn't malfunction.

The officials followed the process they are asked to follow.

Yet when supporters left BMO Stadium on Saturday and Sunday, many weren't talking about tactics, substitutions, or moments of brilliance.

They were talking about handballs.

That's what made this weekend remarkable.

One stadium.

Two matches.

Three handball decisions.

A reminder that football is no longer judged only at full speed.

Sometimes the biggest moments arrive after the play has already stopped.

The field talked.

VAR answered.

Everyone else debated.

The field talks. We listen.

Related Posts

See All

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

FIELDTALK

Fieldtalk is an independent sports storytelling company dedicated to telling the stories behind the game. Guided by our philosophy, "The field talks. We listen.", we capture the people, moments, and communities that define sport.

  • LinkedIn
  • facebook
  • Whatsapp
  • Threads
  • instagram
  • twitter
  • Spotify
  • YouTube
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

©2021 BY FIELDTALK LLC 

About US

Ethics

Privacy Policy

bottom of page